Aaron Burr, 1797 – 1804
Teunis Wortmann, 1804 – 1814
George Buckmaster, 1814 – 1817
Jacob Barker, 1817 – 1822
Stephen Allen, 1822 – 1827
Mordecai M. Noah, 1827 – 1828
Walter Bowne, 1828 – 1835
Isaac Varian, 1835 – 1842
Robert Morris, 1842 – 1848
Isaac Vanderbeck Fowler, 1848 – 1850
Fernando Wood, 1850 – 1856
Isaac Vanderbeck Fowler, 1857 – 1858
Fernando Wood, 1858
William M. Tweed & Isaac Vanderbeck Fowler, 1858 – 1859
William M. Tweed & Richard B. Connolly, 1859 – 1867
William M. Tweed, 1867 – 1871
John Kelly & John Morrissey, 1872
John Kelly, 1872 – 1886
Richard Crocker, 1886 – 1902
Lewis Nixon, 1902
Charles Francis Murphy, Daniel F. McMahon & Louis F. Haffen, 1902
Charles Francis Murphy, 1902 – 1924
George Washington Olvany, 1924 – 1929
John F. Curry, 1929 – 1934
James J. Dooling, 1934 – 1937
Christopher D. Sullivan, 1937 – 1942
Charles H. Hussey, 1942
Michael J. Kennedy, 1942 – 1944
Edward V. Loughlin, 1944 – 1947
Frank J. Sampson, 1947 – 1948
Hugo E. Rogers, 1948 – 1949
Carmine DeSapio, 1949 – 1962
Edward N. Costikyan, 1962 – 1964
J. Raymond Jones, 1964 – 1967
Frank Rosetti, 1967 – 1977
Miriam Bockman, 1977 – 1981
Herman Denny Farrell, Jr., 1981 – 2009
Keith L. T. Wright, 2009 – Present